Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New media
New media comments
New profile posts
Latest activity
Media
New media
New comments
Search media
Members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Other Forums
Star Wars Films
Are we seeing the OT through nostalgic eyes?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Grant_C" data-source="post: 430120" data-attributes="member: 2991"><p>I don't think we are seeing the films through nostalgic eyes. I feel that when people get older, they chose to unknowingly be cynical. This is meant as a generalisation and not anyone in particular or the original poster. But Just read any of the write ups of the new films on here. People define the things they like by highlighting what they didn't like. Focus is on window dressing. Never does the conversation go on directing, editing, costume, set design etc go into any depth, but paragraphs on silly slug creatures that are in the film for 20 seconds.</p><p></p><p>I think it greatly depends on your outlook. I read some of the reviews on here and think, people wouldn't like the OT if they saw it now, especially ROTJ. Are Biker scouts in the film to sell more toys, or is it fun and exciting to add to this infinite universe.</p><p></p><p>I don't think Disney can win no matter what extraordinary lengths they go to. Rogue One for me answered the criticisms of the Prequels and delivered a film for the fan base. I thought it was OT outstanding. I cant wait to get it on Blu-Ray and analyse it properly. I feel on the surface it was a great fun flick, but wonder how much there is to unpack? </p><p></p><p>Is there political commentary about mining for power resources in an occupied holy land a commentary on western imperialism in the Arabian peninsula? Much like the ewok battle in ROTJ was inspired by the American war in Vietnam. </p><p></p><p>I want to know more about the message of trust (trust in the force). The rebels all have to learn to trust in themselves together and the force. The imperials on the other hand have no interest in trust as they only want power. Krenic and Tarkin don't trust each other. Krenic even tries to undermine him by visiting darth vader.</p><p></p><p>On the flip side Kasian learns to trust Jyn, which is an alternate to shooting in the back. Baze and Cherrits releationship is built on trust, Baze is constantly protecting his blind partner. Cherrit trusts in the force and immediately has faith in jyn from the start ("I believe her"). Jyn's mother sets up the film telling Jyn to "Trust the force".</p><p></p><p>These are just personal absorptions from the narrative and text. Its irrelevant if its right or not, as myth is about interpretation, much like religion.</p><p></p><p>Judging by how much has been unpacked by academics in relation to myth, religion, history, politics, influences and filmmaking from the other films, I cant wait to see if this carries the same weight.</p><p></p><p>I love Rogue One, utterly brilliant film. I hope the next one can spark some interest if this one missed the mark.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Grant_C, post: 430120, member: 2991"] I don't think we are seeing the films through nostalgic eyes. I feel that when people get older, they chose to unknowingly be cynical. This is meant as a generalisation and not anyone in particular or the original poster. But Just read any of the write ups of the new films on here. People define the things they like by highlighting what they didn't like. Focus is on window dressing. Never does the conversation go on directing, editing, costume, set design etc go into any depth, but paragraphs on silly slug creatures that are in the film for 20 seconds. I think it greatly depends on your outlook. I read some of the reviews on here and think, people wouldn't like the OT if they saw it now, especially ROTJ. Are Biker scouts in the film to sell more toys, or is it fun and exciting to add to this infinite universe. I don't think Disney can win no matter what extraordinary lengths they go to. Rogue One for me answered the criticisms of the Prequels and delivered a film for the fan base. I thought it was OT outstanding. I cant wait to get it on Blu-Ray and analyse it properly. I feel on the surface it was a great fun flick, but wonder how much there is to unpack? Is there political commentary about mining for power resources in an occupied holy land a commentary on western imperialism in the Arabian peninsula? Much like the ewok battle in ROTJ was inspired by the American war in Vietnam. I want to know more about the message of trust (trust in the force). The rebels all have to learn to trust in themselves together and the force. The imperials on the other hand have no interest in trust as they only want power. Krenic and Tarkin don't trust each other. Krenic even tries to undermine him by visiting darth vader. On the flip side Kasian learns to trust Jyn, which is an alternate to shooting in the back. Baze and Cherrits releationship is built on trust, Baze is constantly protecting his blind partner. Cherrit trusts in the force and immediately has faith in jyn from the start ("I believe her"). Jyn's mother sets up the film telling Jyn to "Trust the force". These are just personal absorptions from the narrative and text. Its irrelevant if its right or not, as myth is about interpretation, much like religion. Judging by how much has been unpacked by academics in relation to myth, religion, history, politics, influences and filmmaking from the other films, I cant wait to see if this carries the same weight. I love Rogue One, utterly brilliant film. I hope the next one can spark some interest if this one missed the mark. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Other Forums
Star Wars Films
Are we seeing the OT through nostalgic eyes?
Top
Bottom