How Do You Rank The SW Movies Now?

[DARTH VADER]

So now that Episode VIII: The Last Jedi has been released, I thought it would be a nice idea to see where the movies rank according to the members of the SWFUK. Note, as good as it is, I have not included Rogue One for obvious reasons.

Regarding the ranking, personally, I will wait until I have seen the latest installment at least one more time - I saw it earlier yesterday evening as it was released earlier over here. I liked it but really need to see it again to digest and give an accurate order...but I believe my first three are well set

[Clarkspie&chips]

What about Rogue 1?

[SAVORY100]

What is the obvious reason to not include Rogue One?

[DARTH VADER]

What is the obvious reason to not include Rogue One?

As the main epic saga is a nine part affair, Rogue One is regarded as an anthology film, a standalone movie.

[Pomse2001]

Oh I must have misunderstood something, I thought the vote was for which movie we think was the best, second, third etc. etc. so I choose all 8

I would have said

The best from top

1. Episode 5
2. Episode 4
3. Episode 6
4. Rogue one if we may have used it
5. Episode 7
6. Episode 8
7. Episode 3
8. Episode 2
9. Episode 1

[SAVORY100]

What is the obvious reason to not include Rogue One?

As the main epic saga is a nine part affair, Rogue One is regarded as an anthology film, a standalone movie.

Ah, I get it... I was confused by the title of the thread "How Do You Rank The SW Movies Now?" as opposed to "How do you rank the 8 SW movies from the three trilogies now?"

You surely understand the confusion... The actual title of Rogue One is Rogue One a Star Wars Story so it seems a fair question for my self and Scott to have raised.

[DARTH VADER]

Yes mate, as soon as I posted the thread, I realised that issue...thread is a good idea, title probably not so much

[Clarkspie&chips]

Lars has the correct order, does he win a prize?

[SAVORY100]

Yes mate, as soon as I posted the thread, I realised that issue...thread is a good idea, title probably not so much

So, all that gubbins aside, how do you want us to vote?
Just our top ranked film?
top 3 or top 4?

Otherwise many will click on all of them (or at least most of them)...

[DARTH VADER]

Lars has the correct order, does he win a prize?

I think Lars probably nailed it too, personally.

Want to see the latest movie again though, so much to digest with that...but it probably sits right where Lars has it.

[DARTH VADER]

Yes mate, as soon as I posted the thread, I realised that issue...thread is a good idea, title probably not so much

So, all that gubbins aside, how do you want us to vote?
Just our top ranked film?
top 3 or top 4?

Otherwise many will click on all of them (or at least most of them)...

The vote option was a mistake, I've just removed it as what Lars has done, i.e. a ranking order, obviously works best. If we follow that pattern, thread should work better.

[Pomse2001]

Lars has the correct order, does he win a prize?

Yes please, what did I win ?

[Pomse2001]

Lars has the correct order, does he win a prize?

I think Lars probably nailed it too, personally.

Want to see the latest movie again though, so much to digest with that...but it probably sits right where Lars has it.

I am glad that I am not the only one that think that is the correct order So did I win anything ?

[av6]

Empire.
Star Wars. (Yes, I still call it that).
Return of the Jedi.
Rogue One. (If we're counting it).
Sith.
Clones.
Menace.
The Holiday Special.
The Last Jedi.

See what I did there.

[DARTH VADER]

Lars has the correct order, does he win a prize?

I think Lars probably nailed it too, personally.

Want to see the latest movie again though, so much to digest with that...but it probably sits right where Lars has it.

I am glad that I am not the only one that think that is the correct order So did I win anything ?

If it was up to me Lars...you'd get the right to officially announce the correct order